| 1 | 1920 Georgia | Thomas E. Watson def. Harry S. Edwards | +89.8 pts |
| 2 | 1934 California | Hiram Johnson def. George R. Kirkpatrick | +89.4 pts |
| 3 | 1940 Texas | Tom Connally def. George I. Shannon | +88.5 pts |
| 4 | 1978 Alabama | Howell Heflin def. Jerome B. Couch | +88.0 pts |
| 5 | 1948 Arkansas | John L. McClellan def. R. Walter Tucker | +86.4 pts |
| 6 | 1932 Georgia | Walter F. George def. James W. Arnold | +85.6 pts |
| 7 | 1936 Texas | Morris Sheppard def. Carlos G. Watson | +85.5 pts |
| 8 | 1942 Virginia | Carter Glass def. Lawrence S. Wilkes | +84.6 pts |
| 9 | 1960 Mississippi | James O. Eastland def. Joe A. Moore | +83.6 pts |
| 10 | 1914 Alabama | Oscar W. Underwood def. Alex C. Birch | +83.4 pts |
| 11 | 1932 Arkansas | Hattie W. Caraway def. John H. White | +79.4 pts |
| 12 | 1938 Arkansas | Hattie W. Caraway def. C. T. Atkinson | +79.2 pts |
| 13 | 1946 Texas | Tom Connally def. Murray C. Sells | +77.1 pts |
| 14 | 1970 Mississippi | John C. Stennis def. William R. Thompson | +76.8 pts |
| 15 | 1918 Georgia | William J. Harris def. G. H. Williams | +76.7 pts |
| 16 | 1922 Florida | Park Trammel def. W. C. Lawson | +76.5 pts |
| 17 | 1952 California | William F. Knowland def. Reuben W. Borough | +75.8 pts |
| 18 | 1950 Louisiana | Russell B. Long def. Charles S. Gerth | +75.4 pts |
| 19 | 1936 Alabama | John H. Bankhead def. H. E. Berkstresser | +74.8 pts |
| 20 | 2006 Indiana | Richard G. Lugar def. Steve Osborn | +74.8 pts |
| 21 | 1928 Wisconsin | Robert M. Lafollette Jr. def. William H. Markham | +74.6 pts |
| 22 | 1918 Texas | Morris Sheppard def. J. Webs Flanagan | +74.3 pts |
| 23 | 1930 Texas | Morris Sheppard def. Doran J. Haesly | +74.2 pts |
| 24 | 2002 Kansas | Pat Roberts def. Steven A. Rosile | +73.4 pts |
| 25 | 2002 Virginia | John William Warner def. Nancy B. Spannaus | +72.8 pts |