| 1914 | U.S. HouseNew York | Won | 22,52358.91% | John J Kelly Amasa J Parker Brown William L Manning |
| 1912 | U.S. HouseNew York | Won | 20,60442.21% | Robert L Drummond H Gould J J Tillapaugh John H Vandenbosch Sr. |
| 1910 | U.S. HouseNew York | Won | 21,12151.81% | John Colmey Edwin Wright V Delos J Cotten |
| 1908 | U.S. HouseNew York | Won | 28,99059.68% | Curtis Leroy Carl Ellis |
| 1906 | U.S. HouseNew York | Won | 25,47562.61% | A S Warner Thomas H Jackson Prosper A Perrin |
| 1904 | U.S. HouseNew York | Won | 29,76061.54% | P H Vanauken John McMillen |
| 1902 | U.S. HouseNew York | Won | 24,13060.11% | Harry B Harpending Hoyt Frank L Brannick |
| 1900 | U.S. HouseNew York | Won | 33,99859.16% | Robert L Drummond Delos J Cotten J Merton Rose |
| 1898 | U.S. HouseNew York | Won | 29,53659.38% | John H Young John W Barrus |
| 1896 | U.S. HouseNew York | Won | 33,62862.37% | Robert L Drummond Francis O Mason Frank Vrooman E Folsom |
| 1894 | U.S. HouseNew York | Won | 29,52861.35% | Eli McConnell Harman S Potter Case |
| 1892 | U.S. HouseNew York | Won | 28,72355.34% | Hull Greenfield Alva H Morrill Case |
| 1890 | U.S. HouseNew York | Won | 17,97050.57% | Edwin K Burnham Charles Mills |
| 1884 | U.S. HouseNew York | Won | 26,44657.09% | Beardsley Bond |
| 1882 | U.S. HouseNew York | Won | 13,60748.76% | Hammond Foster Merchant |