PolitiFinder

2004 New York U.S. House District 4 Election

New York · 2 candidates · See every 2004 U.S. House race

Who won the 2004 New York U.S. House District 4 Election?

Carolyn McCarthy won the 2004 New York U.S. House District 4 Election. Carolyn McCarthy received 159,969 popular votes (52.23%). The main challenger was James A. Garner (30.05%).

See the full head-to-head between McCarthy and Garner

McCarthy +22.2 pts · won by 65,828 votes
Carolyn McCarthyDemocraticWINNER52.23%
159,969 votes
James A. GarnerRepublican30.05%
94,141 votes
Other candidates received the remaining 17.7% of the popular vote; only the leading candidates are individually recorded for this election.
Popular-vote totals for U.S. House elections come from the MIT Election Data and Science Lab (1976–2024).

Data last verified July 28, 2026.