| 1904 | U.S. HouseNew York | Lost | 7631.26% | George Southwick Daniel C McElwain Henry Kruse |
| 1902 | U.S. HouseNew York | Lost | 1230.36% | John Fitzgerald James T Williamson Bernard Hughes Peter Larsen |
| 1896 | U.S. HouseNew York | Lost | 5621.26% | Henry Brewster Ryan Howard W Sneck Frank Siererman John G Davis William J McPherson |
| 1888 | U.S. HouseNew York | Lost | 1,8434.53% | John Raines Dininny |
| 1880 | U.S. HouseNew York | Lost | 9,31332.62% | Fernando Wood John Hardy |
| 1862 | U.S. HouseNew York | Lost | 9,62747.9% | Augustus Frank |
| 1856 | U.S. HouseNew York | Lost | 4,69435.27% | Silas Burroughs George L Church |
| 1842 | U.S. HouseNew York | Lost | 7,59746.52% | Smith Purdy William Avery |
| 1836 | U.S. HouseNew York | Lost | 3,98049.31% | Charles Mitchell |
| 1834 | U.S. HouseNew York | Lost | 3,32045.79% | William Mason |
| 1818 | U.S. HouseNew York | Lost | 10.04% | Henry Storrs Allen Frazer Bacon Huntington William S Hamilton Sill Joel Bristol Evans John Lewis Childs Gamaliel H Barstow Williams John G Davis Hoyt Samuel Dyer David Ostrom Ernest H Woodruff George S Schuyler Samuel F Snowden Charles R Seymour John Doe Andrew Elmer Elmer S White Johnson Luther Guiteau John C Pride |