| Alabama | Rufus W. CobbD | 134,905 votes · +92,542 over James Madison Pickens |
| Arkansas | Thomas James ChurchillD | 84,185 votes · +52,761 over William Pratt Parks |
| Colorado | Frederick Walker PitkinR | 28,465 votes · +4,918 over John S. Hough |
| Connecticut | Hobart B. BigelowR | 67,070 votes · +2,777 over James E. English |
| Florida | William D. BloxhamD | 28,372 votes · +5,065 over Simon B. Conover |
| Georgia | Alfred H. ColquittD | 118,349 votes · +54,345 over Thomas M. Norwood |
| Illinois | Shelby Moore CullomR | 314,565 votes · +37,033 over Lyman Trumbull |
| Indiana | Albert G. PorterR | 231,405 votes · +6,953 over Franklin Landers |
| Kansas | John St. JohnR | 115,144 votes · +51,587 over Edmund G. Ross |
| Maine | Harris M. PlaistedG | 73,713 votes · +169 over Daniel F. Davis |
| Massachusetts | John Davis LongR | 164,926 votes · +53,516 over Charles Perkins Thompson |
| Michigan | David JeromeR | 178,945 votes · +41,243 over Frederick M. Holloway |
| Missouri | Thomas Theodore CrittendenD | 207,670 votes · +54,034 over David Patterson Dyer |
| Nebraska | Albinus NanceR | 55,237 votes · +27,070 over Thomas W. Tipton |
| New Hampshire | Charles H. BellR | 44,434 votes · +3,619 over Frank Jones |
| New Jersey | George C. LudlowD | 121,666 votes · +651 over Frederic A. Potts |
| North Carolina | Thomas Jordan JarvisD | 121,837 votes · +6,278 over Ralph P. Buxton |
| Rhode Island | Alfred H. LittlefieldR | 10,224 votes · +2,784 over Horace A. Kimball |
| South Carolina | Johnson HagoodD | 117,432 votes · +113,155 over L. W. R. Blair |
| Tennessee | Alvin HawkinsR | 103,966 votes · +24,885 over John Vines Wright |
| Texas | Oran Milo RobertsD | 166,101 votes · +101,719 over Edmund J. Davis |
| Vermont | Roswell FarnhamR | 47,848 votes · +26,603 over Edward J. Phelps |
| West Virginia | Jacob B. JacksonD | 60,991 votes · +16,136 over George Cookman Sturgiss |