| Alabama | Rufus W. CobbD | 88,255 votes |
| Arkansas | William Read MillerD | 88,726 votes |
| Colorado | Frederick Walker PitkinR | 14,308 votes · +2,773 over William A. H. Loveland |
| Connecticut | Charles B. AndrewsR | 48,867 votes · +2,482 over Richard D. Hubbard |
| Delaware | John W. HallD | 10,730 votes · +7,895 over Kensey Johns Stewart |
| Kansas | John St. JohnR | 74,020 votes · +36,812 over John R. Goodin |
| Maine | Seldon ConnorR | 56,554 votes · +15,183 over Joseph L. Smith |
| Massachusetts | Thomas TalbotR | 134,725 votes · +25,290 over Benjamin Franklin Butler |
| Michigan | Charles CroswellR | 126,367 votes · +47,819 over Orlando M. Barnes |
| Nebraska | Albinus NanceR | 29,469 votes · +15,996 over William H. Webster |
| Nevada | John Henry KinkeadR | 9,747 votes · +495 over Lewis R. Bradley |
| Oregon | William Wallace ThayerD | 16,201 votes · +69 over Cornelius C. Beekman |
| Pennsylvania | Henry M. HoytR | 319,567 votes · +22,507 over Andrew H. Dill |
| Rhode Island | Charles C. Van ZandtR | 11,454 votes · +3,815 over Isaac Lawrence |
| South Carolina | Wade Hampton IIID | 119,550 votes |
| Texas | Oran Milo RobertsD | 158,302 votes · +103,300 over W. H. Hamman |
| Vermont | Redfield ProctorR | 37,312 votes · +20,065 over W. H. H. Bingham |