| Alabama | Robert B. LindsayD | 77,723 votes · +1,441 over William Russell Smith |
| Connecticut | James E. EnglishD | 44,128 votes · +843 over Marshall Jewell |
| Delaware | James PonderD | 12,459 votes · +2,517 over Thomas B. Coursey |
| Kansas | James M. HarveyR | 40,667 votes · +20,171 over Isaac Sharp |
| Maine | Sidney PerhamR | 54,019 votes · +8,287 over Charles W. Roberts |
| Massachusetts | William ClaflinR | 79,549 votes · +30,869 over John Quincy Adams II |
| Michigan | Henry P. BaldwinR | 100,176 votes · +16,621 over Charles C. Comstock |
| Missouri | Benjamin Gratz BrownR | 104,374 votes · +41,139 over Joseph W. McClurg |
| Nebraska | David ButlerR | 11,126 votes · +2,478 over John H. Croxton |
| Nevada | Lewis R. BradleyD | 7,200 votes · +1,052 over Frederick Augustus Tritle |
| New Hampshire | Onslow StearnsR | 34,912 votes · +9,889 over John Bedell |
| New York | John T. HoffmanD | 399,490 votes · +33,066 over Stewart L. Woodford |
| Oregon | La Fayette GroverD | 11,726 votes · +631 over Joel Palmer |
| South Carolina | Robert Kingston ScottR | 85,071 votes · +33,534 over Richard B. Carpenter |
| Vermont | John W. StewartR | 33,367 votes · +21,309 over Homer W. Heaton |
| West Virginia | John J. JacobD | 29,097 votes · +2,173 over William E. Stevenson |