| Alabama | William Russell SmithR | 62,067 votes |
| Connecticut | James E. EnglishD | 50,541 votes · +1,764 over Marshall Jewell |
| Florida | Harrison ReedR | 14,421 votes · +6,690 over George W. Scott |
| Georgia | Rufus BullockR | 83,527 votes · +7,171 over John B. Gordon |
| Illinois | John M PalmerR | 249,912 votes · +50,099 over John R. Eden |
| Indiana | Conrad BakerR | 171,523 votes · +921 over Thomas A. Hendricks |
| Kansas | James M. HarveyR | 29,795 votes · +15,914 over George Washington Glick |
| Louisiana | Henry C. WarmothR | 64,941 votes · +26,895 over James G. Taliaferro |
| Maine | Joshua ChamberlainR | 75,523 votes · +19,316 over Eben F. Pillsbury |
| Massachusetts | William ClaflinR | 132,121 votes · +68,855 over John Quincy Adams II |
| Michigan | Henry P. BaldwinR | 128,051 votes · +30,761 over John Moore |
| Mississippi | Benjamin G. HumphreysC | 63,321 votes · +8,071 over Beroth B. Eggleston |
| Missouri | Joseph W. McClurgR | 82,090 votes · +19,312 over John S. Phelps |
| Nebraska | David ButlerR | 8,567 votes · +2,218 over James R. Porter |
| New Hampshire | Walter HarrimanR | 39,785 votes · +2,523 over John G. Sinclair |
| New Jersey | Theodore Fitz RandolphD | 83,955 votes · +4,622 over John Insley Blair |
| New York | John T. HoffmanD | 439,301 votes · +27,946 over John Augustus Griswold |
| North Carolina | William Woods HoldenR | 92,235 votes · +18,635 over Thomas Samuel Ashe |
| Rhode Island | Ambrose BurnsideR | 10,038 votes · +4,307 over Lyman Pierce |
| South Carolina | Robert Kingston ScottR | 70,054 votes · +46,958 over William Dennison Porter |
| Vermont | John B. PageR | 42,615 votes · +27,326 over John L. Edwards |
| West Virginia | William E. StevensonR | 26,935 votes · +4,577 over Johnson N. Camden |