| California | Henry Huntly HaightD | 49,905 votes · +9,546 over George Congdon Gorham |
| Connecticut | James E. EnglishD | 47,565 votes · +987 over Joseph Roswell Hawley |
| Iowa | Samuel MerrillR | 90,204 votes · +27,238 over Charles Mason |
| Kentucky | John L HelmD | 90,216 votes · +56,277 over Sidney M. Barnes |
| Maine | Joshua ChamberlainR | 57,713 votes · +11,723 over Eben F. Pillsbury |
| Maryland | Oden BowieD | 63,694 votes · +41,644 over Hugh Lennox Bond |
| Massachusetts | Alexander BullockR | 98,306 votes · +27,946 over John Quincy Adams II |
| Minnesota | William Rainey MarshallR | 34,874 votes · +5,372 over Charles Eugene Flandrau |
| New Hampshire | Walter HarrimanR | 35,809 votes · +3,146 over John G. Sinclair |
| Ohio | Rutherford B. HayesR | 243,605 votes · +2,983 over Allen G. Thurman |
| Rhode Island | Ambrose BurnsideR | 7,372 votes · +4,194 over Lyman Pierce |
| Tennessee | Parson BrownlowR | 74,484 votes · +52,044 over Emerson Etheridge |
| Vermont | John B. PageR | 31,694 votes · +20,184 over John L. Edwards |
| Wisconsin | Lucius FairchildR | 73,637 votes · +4,764 over John J. Tallmadge |