| Connecticut | Joseph Roswell HawleyR | 43,974 votes · +541 over James E. English |
| Delaware | Gove SaulsburyD | 9,810 votes · +1,212 over James Riddle |
| Kansas | Samuel J. CrawfordR | 19,370 votes · +11,218 over James L. McDowell |
| Maine | Joshua ChamberlainR | 69,636 votes · +27,694 over Eben F. Pillsbury |
| Massachusetts | Alexander BullockR | 91,980 votes · +65,309 over Theodore Sweetser |
| Michigan | Henry H. CrapoR | 96,746 votes · +29,038 over Alpheus S. Williams |
| Nebraska | David ButlerR | 4,093 votes · +145 over J Sterling Morton |
| Nevada | Henry G. BlasdelR | 5,125 votes · +1,020 over John D. Winters |
| New Hampshire | Frederick SmythR | 35,137 votes · +4,656 over John G. Sinclair |
| New York | Reuben E. FentonR | 366,315 votes · +13,789 over John T. Hoffman |
| North Carolina | Jonathan WorthN | 34,250 votes · +23,491 over Alfred Dockery |
| Oregon | George Lemuel WoodsR | 10,316 votes · +277 over James K. Kelly |
| Pennsylvania | John W. GearyR | 307,274 votes · +17,178 over Hiester Clymer |
| Rhode Island | Ambrose BurnsideR | 8,197 votes · +5,381 over Lyman Pierce |
| Texas | James W. ThrockmortonD | 48,631 votes · +36,580 over Elisha M. Pease |
| Vermont | Paul DillinghamR | 34,117 votes · +22,825 over Charles N. Davenport |
| West Virginia | Arthur I. BoremanR | 23,802 votes · +6,644 over Benjamin H. Smith |