| Alabama | John Gill ShorterD | 37,849 votes · +9,722 over Thomas Hill Watts |
| California | Leland StanfordR | 56,036 votes · +22,285 over John R. McConnell |
| Connecticut | William Alfred BuckinghamR | 43,012 votes · +2,086 over James Chaffee Loomis |
| Georgia | Joseph E. BrownD | 46,493 votes · +13,691 over E. A. Nisbet |
| Iowa | Samuel J. KirkwoodR | 60,303 votes · +17,058 over William H. Merritt |
| Maine | Israel Washburn Jr.R | 57,475 votes · +36,356 over Charles Davis Jameson |
| Maryland | Augustus BradfordU | 57,472 votes · +31,427 over Benjamin Chew Howard |
| Massachusetts | John Albion AndrewR | 65,261 votes · +33,997 over Isaac Davis |
| Minnesota | Alexander RamseyR | 16,239 votes · +5,841 over Edward O. Hamlin |
| Mississippi | John J. PettusD | 30,169 votes · +26,613 over Jacob Thompson |
| New Hampshire | Nathaniel S. BerryR | 35,467 votes · +4,015 over George Stark |
| Ohio | David TodN | 206,997 votes · +55,203 over Hugh J. Jewett |
| Rhode Island | William Sprague IVC | 12,005 votes · +1,679 over James Y. Smith |
| Texas | Francis LubbockI | 21,854 votes · +124 over Edward Clark |
| Vermont | Frederick HolbrookR | 33,152 votes · +27,430 over Andrew Tracy |
| Wisconsin | Louis P. HarveyN | 53,777 votes · +8,321 over Benjamin Ferguson |