| Alabama | Andrew B. MooreD | 41,871 votes |
| California | John B. WellerD | 53,122 votes · +32,082 over Edward Stanly |
| Connecticut | Alexander H. HolleyR | 31,709 votes · +553 over Samuel Ingham |
| Georgia | Joseph E. BrownD | 57,631 votes · +10,835 over Benjamin Harvey Hill |
| Iowa | Ralph P. LoweR | 38,498 votes · +2,410 over Ben M Samuels |
| Maine | Lot M. MorrillR | 54,655 votes · +11,687 over Manassah H. Smith |
| Maryland | Thomas Holliday HicksK | 47,141 votes · +8,460 over John Charles Groome |
| Massachusetts | Nathaniel BanksR | 60,797 votes · +23,201 over Henry J. Gardner |
| Minnesota | Henry Hastings SibleyD | 17,790 votes · +240 over Alexander Ramsey |
| Mississippi | William McWillieD | 27,377 votes · +13,282 over Edward M. Yerger |
| New Hampshire | William HaileR | 34,216 votes · +3,002 over John S. Wells |
| Ohio | Salmon P. ChaseR | 160,568 votes · +1,503 over Henry B. Payne |
| Pennsylvania | William F. PackerD | 188,846 votes · +42,707 over David Wilmot |
| Rhode Island | Elisha Dyer Jr.R | 9,591 votes · +4,268 over Americus V. Potter |
| Texas | Hardin R. RunnelsD | 32,552 votes · +8,924 over Sam Houston |
| Vermont | Ryland FletcherR | 26,719 votes · +13,850 over Henry Keyes |
| Wisconsin | Alexander W. RandallR | 45,059 votes · +118 over James B. Cross |