| Alabama | John A. WinstonD | 43,930 votes · +11,844 over George Shortridge |
| California | J. Neely JohnsonK | 51,157 votes · +4,937 over John Bigler |
| Connecticut | William T. MinorK | 28,080 votes · +788 over Samuel Ingham |
| Georgia | Herschel V. JohnsonD | 54,136 votes · +10,778 over Garnett Andrews |
| Kentucky | Charles S. MoreheadK | 69,816 votes · +4,403 over Beverly L. Clarke |
| Louisiana | Robert C. WickliffeD | 23,592 votes · +3,837 over Charles Derbigny |
| Maine | Anson MorrillR | 51,441 votes · +3,100 over Samuel Wells |
| Massachusetts | Henry J. GardnerK | 51,497 votes · +14,782 over Julius Rockwell |
| Mississippi | John J. McRaeD | 32,666 votes · +5,087 over Charles D. Fontaine |
| New Hampshire | Ralph MetcalfK | 32,779 votes · +5,729 over Nathaniel B. Baker |
| Ohio | Salmon P. ChaseR | 146,770 votes · +15,751 over William Medill |
| Rhode Island | William W. HoppinW | 11,130 votes · +8,401 over Americus V. Potter |
| Tennessee | Andrew JohnsonD | 67,499 votes · +2,156 over Meredith Poindexter Gentry |
| Texas | Elisha M. PeaseD | 26,336 votes · +7,368 over David C. Dickson |
| Vermont | Stephen RoyceR | 25,654 votes · +13,117 over Merritt Clark |
| Virginia | Henry WiseD | 83,275 votes · +9,921 over Thomas Flournoy |
| Wisconsin | William A. BarstowD | 36,355 votes · +157 over Coles Bashford |