| Arkansas | Isaac MurphyI | 12,418 votes |
| Connecticut | William Alfred BuckinghamN | 39,820 votes · +5,658 over Origen S. Seymour |
| Illinois | Richard J OglesbyN | 190,376 votes · +31,665 over James Carroll Robinson |
| Indiana | Oliver P. MortonN | 152,275 votes · +21,075 over Joseph E. McDonald |
| Kansas | Samuel J. CrawfordR | 13,387 votes · +4,939 over Solon O. Thacher |
| Louisiana | Michael HahnR | 6,158 votes · +3,438 over J. Q. A. Fellows |
| Maine | Samuel ConyN | 65,583 votes · +19,180 over Joseph Howard |
| Maryland | Thomas SwannU | 40,579 votes · +8,511 over Ezekiel F. Chambers |
| Massachusetts | John Albion AndrewR | 125,291 votes · +76,101 over Henry W. Paine |
| Michigan | Henry H. CrapoN | 91,356 votes · +17,063 over William M. Fenton |
| Missouri | Thomas Clement FletcherR | 73,600 votes · +42,536 over Thomas Lawson Price |
| Nevada | Henry G. BlasdelR | 9,834 votes · +3,279 over D. E. Buell |
| New Hampshire | Joseph A. GilmoreN | 37,006 votes · +5,666 over Edward W Harrington |
| New York | Reuben E. FentonN | 369,557 votes · +17,031 over Horatio Seymour |
| Rhode Island | James Y. SmithN | 8,836 votes · +1,524 over George H. Browne |
| Vermont | J. Gregory SmithR | 32,052 votes · +19,415 over Timothy P. Redfield |
| West Virginia | Arthur I. BoremanN | 19,353 votes |