| Alabama | Henry W. CollierD | 37,480 votes · +31,731 over James Shields |
| California | John BiglerD | 23,175 votes · +440 over Pierson B. Reading |
| Connecticut | Thomas H. SeymourD | 30,077 votes · +1,221 over Lafayette S. Foster |
| Georgia | Howell CobbC | 57,417 votes · +18,593 over Charles McDonald |
| Kentucky | Lazarus W. PowellD | 54,821 votes · +798 over Archibald Dixon |
| Michigan | Robert McClellandD | 23,827 votes · +6,926 over Townsend E. Gidley |
| Mississippi | Henry S. FooteU | 29,358 votes · +999 over Jefferson Davis |
| New Hampshire | Samuel Dinsmoor Jr.D | 27,425 votes · +8,967 over Thomas E. Sawyer |
| Ohio | Reuben WoodD | 145,654 votes · +26,106 over Samuel F Vinton |
| Pennsylvania | William BiglerD | 186,489 votes · +8,455 over William F. Johnston |
| Rhode Island | Philip AllenD | 6,935 votes · +829 over Josiah Chapin |
| Tennessee | William B. CampbellW | 63,333 votes · +1,660 over William Trousdale |
| Texas | Peter H. BellD | 13,595 votes · +8,333 over Middleton T. Johnson |
| Vermont | Charles K. WilliamsW | 22,676 votes · +7,726 over Timothy P. Redfield |
| Virginia | Joseph JohnsonD | 67,074 votes · +7,598 over George W. Summers |
| Wisconsin | Leonard J. FarwellW | 22,319 votes · +507 over Don A. J. Upham |