| Arkansas | Thomas S DrewD | 15,866 votes · +15,534 over Reuben T. Redman |
| Connecticut | Clark BissellW | 30,717 votes · +2,192 over George S. Catlin |
| Florida | Thomas BrownW | 4,145 votes · +399 over William Bailey |
| Illinois | Augustus C. FrenchD | 67,828 votes · +62,169 over W. L. D. Morrison |
| Kentucky | John J. CrittendenW | 66,466 votes · +8,421 over Lazarus W. Powell |
| Maine | John W. DanaD | 38,720 votes · +8,982 over Elijah Hamlin |
| Missouri | Austin Augustus KingD | 48,921 votes · +14,953 over James S. Rollins |
| New Hampshire | Jared W. WilliamsD | 32,245 votes · +3,416 over Nathaniel S. Berry |
| New York | Hamilton FishW | 218,776 votes · +95,887 over John Adams Dix |
| North Carolina | Charles ManlyW | 42,536 votes · +854 over David Settle Reid |
| Ohio | Seabury FordW | 148,756 votes · +311 over John Weller |
| Pennsylvania | William F. JohnstonW | 168,522 votes · +297 over Morris Longstreth |
| Rhode Island | Elisha HarrisW | 5,695 votes · +2,012 over Adnah Sackett |
| Vermont | Carlos CoolidgeW | 22,007 votes · +7,076 over Oscar L Shafter |
| Wisconsin | Nelson DeweyD | 19,538 votes · +5,089 over John H. Tweedy |