| Arkansas | Archibald YellD | 10,554 votes |
| Connecticut | William W. EllsworthW | 29,870 votes · +4,600 over John M. Niles |
| Delaware | William B. CooperW | 5,850 votes · +826 over Warren B. Jefferson |
| Indiana | Samuel BiggerW | 62,932 votes · +8,658 over Tilghman Howard |
| Kentucky | Robert P LetcherW | 55,370 votes · +15,711 over Richard French |
| Maine | Edward KentW | 45,574 votes · +67 over John Fairfield |
| Massachusetts | John E. DavisW | 70,884 votes · +15,715 over Marcus Morton |
| Missouri | Thomas ReynoldsD | 29,625 votes · +7,413 over John Bullock Clark |
| New Hampshire | John PageD | 29,521 votes · +8,805 over Enos Stevens |
| New Jersey | William Sanford PenningtonW | 58 votes |
| New York | William H. SewardW | 222,011 votes · +5,285 over William C. Bouck |
| North Carolina | John Motley MoreheadW | 44,484 votes · +8,581 over Romulus M. Saunders |
| Ohio | Thomas CorwinW | 145,442 votes · +16,130 over Wilson Shannon |
| Rhode Island | Samuel Ward KingW | 4,797 votes · +1,379 over Thomas F. Carpenter |
| Vermont | Silas H. JennisonW | 33,435 votes · +10,798 over Paul Dillingham |